The simple changes we made to increase website traffic

Because relying on referrals will only help your business grow so far...

A long time ago, in an internet age far, far away… well, 2016 to be exact, The Good Alliance was formed. But we weren’t the Good Alliance as you know it. No, we did things a little differently back then.

For starters, we initially targeted what we called ‘Socially Motivated Entrepreneurs’, and if we’re honest, we didn’t even know who these businesses were or what they looked like. We were a little green around the gills back then, and we figured we’d recognise them when we saw them.

Niching down wasn’t even on our radar and, over the years, we honed our skills and categorised our target audience into three groups:

  • Charities
  • Social Businesses
  • Solopreneurs

And, to blow our own trumpet a bit, we were pretty damn good at it.

The business grew. We started building our brand through referrals. And because everyone knows one of the best ways to get repeat work is through glowing references, we were sure we were onto a winner.

However, have you ever tried marketing to a diverse range of audiences?

It’s not easy, and something had to change.

Why we had to change.

Every time we worked with a new client, we’d have to reinvent the wheel every time. And although working with different customers in different fields was exciting and fun, it also took a vast amount of energy and brainpower to serve every client and type fully.

It also meant we weren’t solidifying our skills or experience in any given area, so it made it difficult to run the business at a profit.

So, we sat down, talked it through as a team and came to the realisation we could make a significant impact and reach more businesses if we got our act together and actually started to market ourselves.

That’s right, we were telling others the best way to market their business is to be super-specific about whom they’re selling to, but we weren’t actually doing it ourselves. Yes, we wanted to serve all types of businesses and industries in the long run, but in the short-term, we needed to niche down.

By concentrating on one specific customer type, we could work on becoming awesome at serving them. In turn, this would allow us to build and create processes and systems that’d help us to improve our expertise in that area and make us a trusted voice of authority for struggling businesses in that field.

So, to put that right, we reviewed our audience types and assessed them by:

  1. Impact
  2. Profitability
  3. Scalability
  4. Enjoyment

And, unsurprisingly to us, it was our solopreneur clients who came out on top or to be more specific: Coaches.

Why coaches came out top.

great coaching website - example from Mel Noakes

Mel Noakes – The Self Care Coach

We had to make a decision whether we wanted to make a small impact for businesses with a wider reach, like our charity clients. Or whether we wanted to make a massive impact for our coaches, whose audience, although fewer and localised, would gain huge benefits from our knowledge and expertise.

In the end, it just made sense to concentrate on where we could make the biggest difference.

Changes we made to increase website traffic.

At the start of 2019, we made the decision to niche down and, for the next two-years, concentrate on getting results for coaches, not that this meant turning away work from other client types.

However, by focusing our marketing and product development solely on serving our chosen client base, it would allow our team to focus on building workable processes and systems for our coaching clients, which would help us grow as a business and enable us to expand it to a broader audience.

We changed everything and geared it all towards our coach clients, including:

  • Products
  • Marketing
  • Systems
  • Pricing
  • Payment options

And we did this because, unlike our charity and social enterprise clients who covered the costs of our services via grants and loans, our coaching clients tended to pay for them out of their own income — so we set up payment plans to cut costs or space payments out over the course of lengthier projects.

Also, as coaches are very much ‘hands-on’ in their roles, we knew they’d want to invest their own time and energy into refreshing their brand, so we designed three programs, Brand Bootcamp, Marketing Makeover and Impact Amplifier to help them do just that.

Why we went super-specific in our marketing.

Honestly, marketing to lots of different audiences might give you something new to write every day, but it’s freakin’ exhausting too. And we noticed that although we were creating bucket loads of content, it wasn’t engaging our target customers or having much traction.

Once we focused on creating content geared towards attracting coaches, including:

  • Blog posts
  • Newsletters
  • Social Media
  • Opt-ins
  • Sales funnels

It became much easier to create content, and we noticed a massive shift in engagement.

We also noticed coaches rarely had a team around them to manage their website when tweaks or updates were needed, so ‘Website Maintenance’ became a bigger focus for us too.

Website maintenance plans are a hit with coaches.

What initial impact did these changes make?

At first, nothing.


And as a creative business owner, it’s hard to not hit the panic button and switch tactics when results within the first six months didn’t change substantially. However, we decided, as a team, to stick to our guns, sit on our twitchy hands and commit to focusing on the two-year timescale.

What were the results after 12-months?

One year after changing tack, I’m delighted to say that niching down has started to pay off in a big way.

Website visitors 2019–2020

The improvements we’ve seen include:

  • 20x increase in traffic
  • #1 Google ranking for 10 coaching-related keywords
  • 3x increase in weekly & monthly enquiries
  • From 80% of queries being referrals at the beginning of 2019 to 80% of queries coming from website traffic at the beginning of 2020

By holding firm to our beliefs, we’ve seen a dramatic difference in enquiries, income and repeat work within a year. This has allowed us the opportunity to give back by taking on pro-bono work as well as instilling confidence in our ability to grow and serve new audiences in the future.

We’ve learnt a truckload about coaches too.

Okay, we knew a lot already, but by working with them on an individual basis, building them brands and websites and by conducting thorough research, we improved our knowledge on what works and what doesn’t which enabled us to create services and content that has made a significant impact on the businesses of our coaching clients.

What happens next?

With little under a year remaining (at time of writing) of our two-year timescale, it’s more of the same. However, now we have systems in place, it’ll allow us more time to personalise our service.

And with continued growth, we can also start rolling out additional products and services to help more businesses, regardless of whether they’re coaches, charities or social entrepreneurs.

Taking your business to the next level.

Whether you’re looking to rebrand your business or need a helping hand with website maintenance, The Good Alliance can get your business in front of more customers and lighten the load of maintaining your website all by yourself.

If you’re ready to take your business to the next level, visit our Services or Programs pages to see how we can help you.

If you’ve recently rebranded your business either with help from The Good Alliance or off your own back, share your highs and lows in the comments below.

Cat Townsend

Founder of the Good Alliance

After more than a decade spent helping big brands sell more stuff, to people that didn’t need it; Cat set a simple intention: To do more work that made a positive difference in the world. So The Good Alliance was born…

Trying to build an online brand, but not sure where to start?

Our checklist scorecard & planner will help you work out what to focus on next.

Free Download


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You might also be interested in

3 reasons why email marketing is still so successful

Before you write off email as old-fashioned, consider this: email marketing is still one of the...

The ultimate guide to upgrading your coaching website

Everything you need to know about transforming your current coaching website into an asset that...

How to choose your brand colours

If you’re not sending the right signals with your brand colours, let’s figure out which ones will...

10 life coach branding examples to inspire you

Consistent branding builds trust, so if yours is looking a little dated, check out these ten life...

5 things to look for when you need a graphic designer

If you need a graphic designer to make your brand sparkle, here are five things you need to know...

5 things to look for when you need a copywriter

If you need a copywriter to write for your business, how do you know if they’re right for...

5 things to look for when you need a web designer

Unless you’re super design-savvy, you’re going to need a web designer.

If you don’t back up your website files, it’s your fault

If you lose all of your precious files, this is going to sound harsh: you’ve only got yourself to...

What does an exceptional business look like?

If it’s going to go the distance, can lowering your expectations actually make your business...

17 health coaching websites to inspire your own

So good you’ll be itching to make changes to your health coaching website in seconds!

Why you shouldn’t try to serve everyone

Try to serve everyone and you’ll find yourself losing clients.

5 reasons why you’ve got writer’s block

If you’re stuck for words, here’s five reasons why – and what you can do to fix...
Not sure where to start?
Building a brand can feel overwhelming. This guide will help you figure out where you should start and what you should focus on next.
This free guide will help you figure out where you should start and what you should focus on next.